iPhones: Silos of the Soul

Not long ago, our family enjoyed an all-too-rare evening at home. But as I looked around the family room, I was annoyed. All five of us were on different devices; We were in the same space, but we were not engaged with one another. To use MIT researcher Sherry Turkle’s phrase, we were “alone together.”

“Kids, put away the phones and iPads,” I announced. “We’re going to watch a movie and all look at the same screen the way God intended.”

It’s remarkable how our criteria for togetherness has changed. When I was a kid, it was considered a failure for a family to merely watch TV together; We were told to aim for meals around the table with real conversation. Now that sounds as culturally inconceivable as practicing sexual abstinence or enjoying McDonalds. In a world saturated with personal digital devices, getting a household to silently watch television together is an uncommon victory.

With the release of the updated Apple iPhone this week, I’ve been thinking about the gap between what these devices promise us and what they actually deliver; Smart phones promise us instant access to the world and immediate contact with anyone, anywhere. They carry the potential to erase physical and cultural boundaries. With the ability to translate speech on the fly, the devices in our pockets offer us what Pope Francis called the, “immense possibility for encounter and solidarity.”

Why, then, do we feel more isolated than ever? Why is our culture feeling more fractured, tribal, and disunited? Why are political extremes more acute and compromises more rare? Why is religious fundamentalism on the rise and civil pluralism more difficult to foster? Why can’t I get my family to watch American Ninja Warrior together?

In his remarks about technology, the Pope said the Internet is “something truly good, a gift from God.” However, the pontiff also saw how the proliferation of content can lead to disconnection. “The variety of opinions being aired can be seen as helpful, but it also enables people to barricade themselves behind sources of information which only confirm their own wishes and ideas, or political and economic interests.”

In other words, technology has enabled birds of a feather to flock together as never before. We can self-select a digital life of comfort in which we avoid any person or idea that we do not like. Rather than offering “encounter and solidarity,” as the Pope instructs, our smartphones more often than not create isolation and tribalism. They have become silos for our souls that disconnect us from engaging the uncomfortable people that might provoke the growth of our minds and hearts—including the uncomfortable people in our own households.

I don’t have a simple solution to this problem. I don’t think we can simply retreat to an era before iPhones and social media. That Pandora’s box—beautifully designed by Jony Ives—has been opened and cannot be shut. Instead, we must learn the discipline of encounter once again. It is the discipline of choosing to engage with those who make us uncomfortable and recognizing that in the face of the “other” I may discover the face of God.

This hard work of encounter was once forced upon our species by the need to survive, work, and reproduce, but technology has now made it entirely optional.  If we have any chance of recovering the blessings of encounter, then it must be fostered in our homes. Perhaps it can begin when families periodically turn off their smartphone to watch television together the way God intended.


 

WithGodHeader_1200v1

Stop just living your life FOR God, and starting living WITH him. The new With God Daily Devotional by Skye Jethani is delivered to your inbox every morning with reflections on Scripture, theology, culture, history, and current events. The brief readings, Scripture, and prayers are designed to transform your vision of God and his world each day by drawing you into a deeper awareness of his presence. If you’ve read WITH, don’t miss this resource for developing your communion with God.

Sign Up for the Devotional


Stay up-to-date on Skye's posts, new books, speaking engagements and more.

6 Comments

  • October 2, 2015

    henry

    Check out this related article by Turkle. It takes this discussion from the living room to the classroom. http://chronicle.com/article/How-to-Teach-in-an-Age-of/233515/?key=HjomIgVpZ3JHYHkxYj1KbjlSOHBrNx59MHIfOX98bl5TFg==

  • […] “‘Kids, put away the phones and iPads,’ I announced. ‘We’re going to watch a movie and all look at the same screen the way God intended.’” Skye Jethani looks at what it means to be alone together. […]

  • […] Home Alone: The Lies That Tie us to our Phones and along similar lines iPhones: Silos of the Soul […]

  • October 7, 2015

    Cornelia Becker Seigneur

    Skye- I totally agree with you on this and find my pen often turning to this topic! As the mom of five kids constantly trying to keep my kids engaged with their families, it is ad adventure for sure. Setting limits –announcing tech-free hours – or vacations or meals — is one way for sure. And the kids will thank us for it later. My twins were at Young Life Malibu camp last summer where there were no personal tech devices allowed.When they got off the ferry, they were given their devices back and everyone went back to isolation, or being alone together, as you call it here. One of my twins, who is usually the most tech-addicted of my kids, announced that he wished everyone would just stay off their phones! –

  • October 12, 2015

    Heath Davis

    Skye,

    Appreciate your words, especially the American Ninja Warrior comment. I so can relate! One writer I read a while back talked about how the entertainment center and (subsequently the TV) has replaced the hearth as the gathering place for the family and how detrimental that was. And, now we find our selves longing for the good ol’ days where we all watched movies around the same entertainment center. It’s insane. I think that we can still re-create hearth-like settings in our families, but in my house it requires a lot of creativity and intentionality. And, the silos of the soul have to be left behind in order to experience such moments.

    Thanks for the post.

  • April 28, 2016

    jstill711@aol.com

    I’m questioning if there’s an important point being missed in this entire dialogue. If our goal is encounters and engagement with our family, I’m fairly sure that watching a television show won’t accomplish that. As Heath points out above, the television, or any electronic form of entertainment, is detrimental to family life. Do it in moderation, but make time to experience healthy activities, play games around the table(yes, even teenagers will do this!), and share gratitude and prayer requests. It’s not too late to make family life a priority…take the first step today!